Divisions in Africa over GM crops

Source: African Centre for Biosafety
This book provides an overview of the current status of the use of genetic engineering in Africa's agriculture and food systems. December 2007. [see more]
With the strong backing of certain aid agencies and the biotechnology industry, West African leaders are turning increasingly in favour of using biotechnology in agriculture. The term “biotechnology” covers many areas, but here the aspect causing the most controversy is GM seed technology. While supporters in the region emphasise the importance of not missing out on the potential of this new technology, there remain many issues with regards to proper regulation and the likely dependence of small scale farmers on multinational seed companies if introduced.

Developmental agencies such as USAID and many bodies within the UN present GM seed technology as a vital tool for increasing crop yields, thereby helping to secure food security and lift farmers out of poverty. On the other hand, many campaign groups from the region highlight other factors equally pressing for improving crop yields such as poor irrigation. Furthermore, with regards to cash crops, for those farmers who do receive high yields, many consider that restrictive trade barriers and heavy subsidies maintained by Western nations represent much greater barriers to achieving profit. Finally, recognising that the issue of food security is very complex (see Choike’s in-depth report Agriculture and food sovereignty for more detailed discussion) although higher crop yields will help in many cases to secure better food security in countries, the example of the famine in Niger in 2005 shows that food distribution and trade mechanics (keeping food prices too high for the population to afford) equally need to be addressed.

In addition to the popular debates arising from health and environmental concerns more generally, a major issue for the region concerning the introduction of GM seed technology is the lack of knowledge on behalf of the local communities or public debate of the issues at stake. Under the Convention on Biological Diversity, it is the responsibility of governments to inform and consult the people before allowing the introduction of GMOs, and the African Model Law on Biosafety requires that the public be engaged in the decision-making process (Art.5). However, very few countries are applying these principals.

Nonetheless, increasing action by civil society groups is aiming to readdress this and open up the debate. These groups are emphasising issues such as the protection of genetic heritage and the impact on small scale farmers of the likely dependence on foreign multinationals for access to seeds they have cultivated for centuries.

Current situation

The country most advanced in research into GM crops in the region is currently Burkina Faso, which authorised trials on Bt and VIP variety cotton in 2003. In 2005 Ghana drafted biosafety legislation and key officials expressed their intentions to pursue research into GM crops.

Yet other countries in the region are taking more cautious measures. Benin introduced a moratorium on GM crops in 2002 (1) and more recently Mali stopped plans to produce a law permitting trials on GM crops in February 2006 (2), under pressure from consumer groups and civil society organisations.

1) see fact sheet from FAO and article in French describing the event.
2) mentioned here -in French- originally in Le Monde)
Imprimir   Enviar    Correct 
Thursday, December 20 2007
GMOs in Africa: food and agriculture status report 2007
(Source: African Centre for Biosafety)
Thursday, September 06 2007
The new green revolution in Africa: trojan horse for GMOs?
(Source: African Centre for Biosafety)
Thursday, March 23 2006
Citizens space for democratic deliberation on GMOs and the future of farming in Mali
(Source: International Institute for Environment and Development)

Status of research in countries and introduction to the debate

The new green revolution in Africa: trojan horse for GMOs? (African Centre for Biosafety)

Developing Country Biotechnology Profiles (FAO)

The Case for and against GMOs in Africa (Black Britain)

GMOs in Africain Agriculture – West Africa (African Centre for Biosafety)

A "seed monopoly"?

Mali's David v Goliath GM struggle (BBC)

US: Monsanto “Seed Police” Scrutinise Farmers Article (CorpWatch)

Canada's Top Court Backs Monsanto Against Farmer (IPS)

Seeds of Distraction (ZNet)


Citizens space for democratic deliberation on GMOs and the future of farming in Mali (International Institute for Environment and Development)

Mali Farmers Reject GM Crops as Attack on Their Way of Life (The Independent)

Africa must say no to GMO (IPS)

Mali's David v Goliath GM struggle (BBC)

Statement by civil-society on biotech ECOWAS conference (GRAIN)

GM cotton is dividing African producers (Le Monde)

GMO and food sovereignty (abcBurkina)

Nairobi Declaration on “GMO in African agriculture” (GRAIN)

La coalition pour la protection du patrimoine génétique africain

Out of Africa: Mysteries of Access and Benefit Sharing (Edmonds Institute)

Biosafety Regulation

African Model Law on safety in Biotechnology, Addis Ababa, June 1999

Africans missing at key biosafety talks (Panos)

Ghana drafts biosafety legislation. (Science and Development Network)

Genetically Engineered Crops and Foods: Worldwide Regulation and Prohibition (Center for Food Safety)

Fact Sheets On Biotechnology and Biosafety (Consumers International)

Voices in favour: Industry pressure, development bodies endorsement and government reactions

U.S. Announces Launch of West Africa Cotton Improvement Program (US Trade Representative)

Official report from the Ministerial conference of the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS) on biotechnol (West and Central African Council for Agricultural Research and Development)

West African leaders give cautious thumbs up to biotech (IRIN News)

Realising the Promise of Green Biotechnology for the Poor (UN Economic Comission for Africa)

International Service for the Acquisition of Agri-biotech Applications (ISAAA) (ISAAA)

Focus on Africa (GMWatch)

Results of research so far

GMOs in Africa: food and agriculture status report 2007 (African Centre for Biosafety)

GM cotton still dividing all those involved (IPS)

GM cotton set to invade West Africa (GRAIN)

Burkina Faso Considers Use of Genetically Modified Cotton (IPS)

Choike is a project of the Third World Institute
www.choike.org | Contact | Avda. 18 de julio 2095/301, Montevideo 11200, Uruguay | Phone: +598 2403 1424